“Supposed Killed or Drowned by Enemy Action at Sea” Scottish Merchant Navy women who died as a result of enemy action in the First and Second World Wars

We are delighted to host a blog by Dr Nina Baker about the courageous women seafarers who made the ultimate sacrifice in wartime. Nina has had a varied career, having sailed for seven years as a merchant navy deck officer on leaving school, and later taken an engineering design degree in her 30s, from the University of Warwick. She then gained a PhD in concrete durability from the University of Liverpool. She has lived with her family in Glasgow since 1989, working variously as a materials lecturer in further education and as a university research administrator and, until 2017, as an elected city councillor. Now retired from all that, her interest in promoting STEM careers for girls has led her to become an independent researcher, mainly specialising in the history of women in engineering. She was Deacon of the Incorporation of Hammermen of Glasgow for 2022-2023. She has been a Deputy Lieutenant in the Glasgow Lieutenancy since 2017 and was appointed an OBE in the 2023 New Year’s Honours’ list, for services to the history of women in engineering.

Nina’s new book is available as a paperback from Lulu.com and Amazon and as an ebook from Lulu.com.


My book is the first complete list of the female professional seafarers in the United Kingdom’s Merchant Navy who lost their lives due to enemy action. I decided to do this research because I started to wonder who the women might be whose names are in the National Merchant Navy Roll of Honour. At the annual Merchant Navy Memorial Day events, some of these names are read out but we knew nothing about the women and their lives. The National Roll of Honour is represented in book form in volumes on display in the entrance to Glasgow City Chamber but also in a built form as the National Merchant Navy Memorial structures at Tower Hill, London, on which the names are listed on cast bronze plates. Both are incomplete. As a former Merchant Navy seafarer myself, and having lived in Scotland for more than half my life, I decided to research detailed profiles for those women who were of Scottish background, bringing their stories to light for the first time.

Neoclassical stone war memorial at Tower Hill in London, featuring a row of tall columns, dark engraved bronze panels listing names of the fallen, and an inscribed entablature above the colonnade.
National Merchant Navy Memorial, Tower Hill, London

The majority of these women, either born in Scotland or for whom their last known address was in Scotland, were of working-class origins: from families where the men were deckhands, dockworkers or shipbuilders. Of those from Glasgow, many lived in the Govan area, which was then and is now predominantly working-class and has the only major shipbuilding yard on the Clyde.

Black-and-white newspaper clipping with the headline “THE PASSING OF MASHIE” and subheading “Tribute to a Stewardess,” above a smaller captioned image reading, “Lifeboats with survivors from a torpedoed ship take to the open sea.”
Article by the Elysia’s radio officer about their much-loved stewardess

As an example, Stewardess Catherine McWatt Armstrong, whose shipboard nickname was ‘Mashie’, we know quite a lot about the sort of person she was because the Radio Officer on board her ship, the SS Elysia, wrote a charming eulogy following her death when the ship was sunk in the Indian Ocean in 1942. We know that she was their “… only stewardess – the only woman on board. She was middle-aged and dumpy, with little fat legs, and she wore thick-lensed, steel-rimmed spectacles. Mashie was a Scotswoman, not dour by any means, but she was blunt of speech and saw no reason to smile for no purpose. But when there was a reason her smile was good to see.” And we know that she was sanguine about her fate: “… she was quietly scornful of all the preparations for emergency. Foolish, you may well say, but that was Mashie. After all, she had been in some tough blitzes with us and when Glasgow had its worst air raid she sat in her beloved little flat in Govan, high up in a tenement, when everybody in Glasgow who had any sense at all was in an air-raid shelter. She sat knitting in the dark. She told us so without a suspicion of boastfulness. It isn’t the sort of thing one boasts about any more in Britain. It’s just plain stupidity. But not in Mashie’s case. It was faith with Mashie: faith that she could not be harmed unless it were God’s will.”

Black-and-white photograph of the steamship “Elysia” underway at sea, showing a long dark hull, central funnel emitting smoke, masts with rigging, and crew visible along the decks.
SS Elysia

When the call to abandon ship was sounded, she stayed on board until the very last moment, to help the doctor with injured passengers. The lifeboat she got into was damaged and lost with all on board. Her courage earned her a posthumous Merchant Navy Commendation (equivalent to a Mention in Dispatches).

Front cover of a book featuring an illustration of Athenia survivors in a lifeboat, with the title “Supposed Killed or Drowned by Enemy Action at Sea” and author credit to Dr Nina Baker OBE.

Her courage was remarkable but not exceptional amongst these women. There are numerous stories of how such women’s duty (and inclination), in an emergency, was not to rush up and out to their lifeboat station but to go in and down towards the group of cabins for which they were responsible, in order to ensure that their passengers got out safely.

Most names on public war memorials are military men’s names, with a very few for Merchant Navy seafarers, let alone women. Among the Merchant Navy seafarers who sailed voyage after voyage in war time, knowing that each one might be their last as so many ships were sunk by enemy action, were a few women.

Now, for the first time, complete lists of all known Merchant Navy women lost in the two world wars are provided and are enhanced by biographies of the Scottish women who made the final sacrifice. Nearly all have no grave but the sea.

Text Copyright © 2026 Nina Baker

Cite this page as: Nina Baker, ‘Scottish Merchant Navy women who died as a result of enemy action in the First and Second World Wars’, Women’s History Scotland blog (05 March 2026), https://womenshistoryscotland.org/?p=3960, accessed [todays date]


To contribute to our blog, please get in touch!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *