“Shaking Up Women’s Thinking”: the Scottish Convention of Women, 1977-79
In our May blog, one of our 2023 WHS Research Bursary Winners shares his research on the Scottish Convention of Women. Tom Chidwick is the Manager of the Mile End Institute at the Queen Mary University of London and is the Co-Director of the Edward Heath Academic Forum, a new scholarly network established by the Sir Edward Heath Charitable Foundation to encourage the study of the politics of the 1970s. He was a regular columnist for Scottish Review from March 2020 until its closure in November 2023. His first book, Now or Never! A History of the first Scottish Devolution Referendum, will be published by Bloomsbury Academic in 2025.
On Saturday 5 February 1977, a little under a year after the conclusion of the United Nations’ International Women’s Year, more than 100 women from across Scotland gathered at the Netherbow Theatre in Edinburgh to establish a pioneering ‘national resource and advice centre’.
Intended to be a ‘fairly flexible forum in which individuals, groups, and organisations could share in informed discussion’, the Convention of Scottish Women – quickly renamed the Scottish Convention of Women, fearing that its moniker would exclude those who had been born outside Scotland – was the product of twelve months of planning by a Steering Committee, chaired by the former president of the Women’s Guild of the Church of Scotland, Maidie Hart. The fourteen-strong group was made up of members of the country’s International Women’s Year committee (including Margaret, Countess of Marr, who had recently succeeded to Scotland’s oldest earldom) as well as representatives of the Scottish Council of Social Service, the Scottish Trades Union Congress (STUC), the British Federation of University Women, the Scottish Pre-School Playgroups Association, and the Conservative, Labour, and Scottish National Parties. The Convention’s purpose was to exploit the ‘contacts, cooperation, and initiatives’ that its Steering Committee had made during International Women’s Year to:
- Help women to realise their potential and to direct their efforts towards improving the use of our resources in Scotland and enhancing the quality of life for all.
- Secure the cooperation and involvement of individual women, women’s groups, and established organisations in Scotland.
- Identify areas of need in Scotland, and provide opportunities for initiative, study, and action.[1]
For women in particular, Scotland in the 1970s was not experiencing a shortage of ‘areas of need’. In addition to the fact that domestic violence constituted a quarter of all reported violent crime in Scotland and 68 per cent of all Scottish women workers were low-paid, many activists were confronted by the prevalence of the assumption that ‘if you were a feminist in the 1970s … you wore a woolly hat, forced your children to be homosexual, looked like the “back end of a bus” and hated men’.[2] While women were the sole earners in over 400,000 households across the UK in the 1970s and made up 43 per cent of Scotland’s permanent workforce, their average hourly earners as a percentage of men were just 70.8 per cent, some 2.9 per cent lower than that of their sisters in England and Wales.[3]
‘if you were a feminist in the 1970s … you wore a woolly hat, forced your children to be homosexual, looked like the “back end of a bus” and hated men’
With approximately 1.1 million women, aged 15-44 living in Scotland when the Convention was established, SCOW believed that one of its most important functions would be to help other women’s groups establish themselves, telling its members that there can be ‘real value in a community or a small cluster of organisations making a collective effort’. As the first significant umbrella women’s organisation, it sought to build on the educative work of existing social and religious groups such as the Young Women’s Christian Association, the Women’s Guild, and the Pakistani Women’s Committee – who all sent representatives to SCOW meetings – by encouraging its members to be ‘better informed about current issues’ and ‘consequently better prepared to contribute’ to its work to ‘shake up women’s thinking about themselves and society’s attitudes’.[4]
Unlike Scottish Women’s Aid which received long-term funding from the Scottish Office after establishing its first refuges in Edinburgh and Glasgow in 1973/74, the Convention was entirely dependent on the time and subscription fees of its members. Still, it did seek to maintain a close working relationship with the state. In its early years, its willingness to seek areas of agreement with the Scottish Office and the country’s major political parties caused it to be viewed with suspicion and apathy by other women’s organisations. During the two years between the Convention’s first meeting and the country’s first national referendum – which would determine whether a devolved Assembly would be established to oversee Scotland’s social policy (including the National Health Service, welfare, and education) as well as sex and rape, marriage, and divorce – the Convention undertook a widespread lobbying campaign. Its working party on devolution drafted and sent a three-page questionnaire to the Conservative, Labour, Liberal, and SNP research departments to determine how they would rectify the underrepresentation of women, how they would configure the Assembly to ensure that ‘equal consideration’ would be given to women on departmental select committees, how they would recruit more women into the Civil Service and whether they would establish new extra-government organisations (including a separate Scottish Equal Opportunities Commission) to ensure that women’s views were ‘built into’ the new system.
While many groups were indifferent to the Assembly – with one article in the Scotsman suggesting that they had left ‘the winning of the Assembly to the men; or at least the political parties, which is pretty much the same thing’ – SCOW unofficially endorsed its creation. It did not explicitly call for a ‘Yes’ vote, but its founders did appear at a press conference with key ‘Yes’ campaigners including the future Labour MP George Foulkes and Peter Gibson (the Director of the Scottish Consumer Council) calling for an end to the ‘log jam’ at Westminster.[5] While the Assembly’s demise meant that Scottish women still had ‘no [formal] means of lobbying our MPs locally nor of feeling nearer to the seat of Government’, SCOW endured for over a decade, finally being wound up in favour of Engender in 1992, providing Scottish women with a new coordinating forum to meet, exchange ideas, and covey their ‘informed opinion’ to government.[6]
I am very grateful to Women’s History Scotland for supporting this research as I prepare to contribute a chapter to a new edited collection on Women, Power and Politics in Britain from 1945 to 1997, which will be published by Oxford University Press in 2025. The WHS Research Bursary is open to masters students, doctoral researchers, early career researchers, and, importantly, independent historians. You can apply for this year’s Research Bursary until 31 May 2024 here.
[1] National Library of Scotland, Acc.9395 [Box 4/File 2], The Scottish Convention of Women Papers (SCOW), ‘Constitution of SCOW’ (18 March 1978).
[2] While exact figures for the 1970s can be hard to come by, these estimates are from the STUC which represented the country’s approximately 265,000 trade unionists. See Glasgow Women’s Library [GWL], Low Pay Amongst Women (STUC Women’s Committee Low Pay Conference, 23 August 1986), pp.2-4; GWL, Scottish Women’s Charter: Proposals designed to extend women’s control over their lives (Women’s Legal and Financial Independence Group, 1978), p.6.
[3] Ibid.
[4] NLS, Acc.9395 [Box 4/File 2], Scottish Convention of Women Prospectus (October 1980), p.1.
[5] ‘Social affairs lobby in favour of devolution’, The Scotsman, 19 February 1979.
[6] NLS, Acc.9395 [Box 4/File 2], ‘Paper E: Memorandum from Maidie Hart to SCOW members’ (Undated but likely to be from Summer 1979).
Text Copyright © 2024 Thomas Chidwick
Cite this page as: Thomas Chidwick, ‘ “Shaking Up Women’s Thinking”: the Scottish Convention of Women, 1977-79’, 16 May 2024, https://womenshistoryscotland.org/?p=3109, accessed [todays date]
Twitter: Tom Chidwick (@TomChidwick) / X (twitter.com)
To contribute to our blog, please get in touch!
