This month we are delighted to publish a blog written by Hannah Speed, a member of the WHS Steering Committee. She is a PhD student at the University of Glasgow, researching ‘Women’s Life-writing and the Suffrage Campaign in Scotland, c.1870s-1970s’. Her blog provides valuable insight into the various issues discussed by women readers of Forward, a socialist newspaper published in Scotland from 1906 to 1960.
While newspapers are a popular source for historians, looking beyond their articles to their letters page can reveal new insights. We can explore which women were writing to newspapers, how they chose to present themselves, and the issues in which they were interested.
The Glasgow-based Forward newspaper (1906-1960), edited by Tom Johnston, was one of the most successful local socialist papers of its time.[1] This blog is based on analysis of a sample of letters in its early years (1906-1919). Only a minority of the letters featured in the periodical were from women, and it is not uncommon to find issues with no women’s letters whatsoever. Nonetheless, some women did write. Correspondents ranged from local Glasgow women to Londoners, and from less well-known or well-off individuals to wealthier women and leaders of political campaigns, all writing about a variety of topics.
Readers trusted Forward to represent them and draw attention to their causes. One unnamed writer appealed to the periodical when her husband went to prison and her wage could not support her children, asking for help to obtain financial aid from the council. Despite being almost destitute, she still showed her allegiance to the paper, noting, ‘I have read your paper every week for some time.’[2] Forward also received a letter from ‘Counter Girl’, who wrote in response to an article about Cranston’s Tea Rooms in Glasgow. Forward accused the owner of poor employment practices, but he denied any problems. She felt strongly enough to risk speaking out to defend her fellow women workers: ‘I as an employee beg to state that Stuart Cranston’s answer is only a blind. He says we are all satisfied. But what can we do? Girls work here from 8:30a.m. to 7:00p.m. But how can we better ourselves?’[3] She drew on her experiences and presented herself as an exploited worker to publicly expose poor conditions and women’s limited employment prospects.
‘I wish to add my quota of protest not because I am myself a woman, but because I am a Socialist, and I desire to avoid the misunderstanding… of the aims and doctrines of Socialism.’
Women wrote to Forward about a variety of feminist issues, with the vote being a common topic. For example, Ellen Smyth complained about a visiting socialist lecturer who had argued against women’s suffrage and advanced education: ‘I wish to add my quota of protest not because I am myself a woman, but because I am a Socialist, and I desire to avoid the misunderstanding… of the aims and doctrines of Socialism.’[4] She identified herself first and foremost as a socialist, and used this position to argue that for the good of the movement, true socialism would respect women and stamp out sexism. By contrast, a later letter surfaced tensions between the suffrage and labour/socialist movements. Glasgow suffragette Margaret McPhun wrote to defend the methods of the Women’s Social and Political Union, which had disrupted a Labour meeting, arguing ‘our attack on Mr. [Ramsey] MacDonald is inspired by just indignation for his neglect of duty and betrayal of our cause.’[5]

The First World War prompted further discussion of women’s role. For example, ‘Marion E. Duggan LL.B’ (a law graduate who would later become one of the first women barristers in Ireland) wrote to Forward about allowing women to replace male labour during the war.[6] She pointedly proposed: ‘Why not immediately admit women as barristers and solicitors so that men may be free to go to the front? A number of women have taken brilliant degrees in Law’.[7] By signing with her degree title, Duggan placed herself amongst this group of learned women who could serve the war effort if only they were allowed. Women had only relatively recently been formally admitted to universities and some professions, and were still barred from becoming lawyers.[8] Her letter reminded readers that women were capable of advanced study, professional work, and participation in public life. The letters pages of Forward were also used to gain support for campaigns such as pacifism. Leading suffragette, socialist and pacifist Helen Crawfurd wrote to promote the Women’s Peace Crusade.[9] She drew together her audience, speaking of ‘we women’ who were suffering the ‘ghastly slaughter of our sons, our husbands, our brothers’, and called them to action: ‘Women come and support us at our meetings, help financially… let the voice of women be heard.’[10]
These examples are just a small fraction of women readers’ letters to Forward, which present a fascinating source for further research. Letters to the editor are valuable as one of the few sources available to understand the subjectivities of working-class or grassroots labour/socialist women, who were less likely to leave autobiographies, diaries or private correspondence. Even for more well-known women, their letters are a different form of self-presentation to their published articles, books or speeches. As this sample shows, letters to newspapers reveal the views and experiences of a variety of women, in their own words, which we may not otherwise be able to access.
To read more of Hannah Speed’s research, please note her forthcoming article: ‘The Edinburgh movement for women’s higher education through the eyes of its founder: what can the writings and biography of Mary Crudelius reveal about the campaign (1866-1877)?’, Scottish Archives [Forthcoming, 2024]
Text Copyright © 2023 Hannah Speed
Cite this page as: Hannah Speed, “Women Readers’ Letters to the Glasgow Forward, 1906-1919,” Women’s History Scotland blog (12 August 2023), https://womenshistoryscotland.org/?p=2800, accessed [today’s date]
References
[1] June Hannam, ‘New Histories of the Labour Movement’, in Re-presenting the Past: Women and History, eds Ann-Marie Gallagher, Cathy Lubelska and Louise Ryan (Harlow: Longman, 2001), p.165. June Hannam and Karen Hunt, ‘Propagandising as Socialist Women: The Case of the Women’s Columns in British Socialist Newspapers, 1884-1914’, in Propaganda: Political Rhetoric and Identity 1300-2000, eds Bertrand Taithe and Tim Thornton (Stroud: Sutton Publishing, 1999), p.168.
[2] Anon., ‘A Heart Break Letter’, Forward, 8 March 1913, p.4.
[3] ‘Counter Girl’, ‘Cranston’s Tea-room Wages’, Forward, 29 April 1911, p.6.
[4] Ellen Smyth, ‘Russell Smart and Women’, Forward, 12 March 1910, p.1.
[5] Margaret McPhun, ‘General Botha’s Methods’, Forward, 21 February 1914, p.3.
[6] Ivana Bacik, Cathryn Costello and Eileen Drew, Gender Injustice: Feminising the Legal Professions? (Dublin: Trinity College Dublin Law School, 2003), p. 53., pp.57-8.
[7] Marion E. Duggan, ‘Some Questions for Politicians During the War’, Forward, 6 March 1915, p.2.
[8] Gerry Holloway, Women and Work in Britain Since 1840 (London: Routledge, 2005), p.118., p.126.
[9] June Hannam and Karen Hunt, Socialist Women: Britain, 1880s to 1920s (London: Routledge, 2002), p.43.
[10] Helen Crawfurd, ‘Mrs Pankhurst: Whom Does She Represent?’, Forward, 16 June 1917, p.2.
To contribute to our blog, please get in touch!

Such an interesting and illuminating post. Thanks!